Question 110
During a migration readiness assessment at Horizon Energy Services, the tenant administration team identifies this issue: A single sign-on deployment is expected to grant every application role simply because the user authenticated once. The responsible team reports that it has applied the correction. Which evidence BEST verifies that the original issue was resolved?
Explanation
Correct Answer
A user signs in once but is denied an application role that was never assigned. This is the relevant proof because it tests whether the selected corrective action (Keep application authorization decisions separate from the convenience of a shared single sign-on session) addressed the initiating problem (A single sign-on deployment is expected to grant every application role simply because the user authenticated once) in Horizon Energy Services's remote field-worker sign-ins and operations environment, not merely whether a task was marked complete.
Incorrect Answers
A valid federated user session still fails a resource authorization check unless the intended local role is assigned. This is useful evidence for a different situation (A directory administrator believes identity federation automatically copies every authorization permission from a partner tenant) and action (Document the federation authentication trust separately from locally configured application roles and access policy). For the reported issue at Horizon Energy Services, it does not establish the required outcome: A user signs in once but is denied an application role that was never assigned.
The export runs with an auditable workload identity and an unrelated privilege request is denied. This is useful evidence for a different situation (A scheduled data export is run using a shared employee password because the team assumes only human beings can have identities) and action (Assign the nonhuman workload a governed service identity and scoped authorization instead of a personal account). For the reported issue at Horizon Energy Services, it does not establish the required outcome: A user signs in once but is denied an application role that was never assigned.
Sign-in evidence confirms the person was authenticated while the resource audit records a distinct permission denial. This is useful evidence for a different situation (A user enters correct credentials but cannot open a restricted payroll application and the help desk treats the failure as unsuccessful authentication) and action (Separate authentication of the identity from subsequent authorization to the payroll resource). For the reported issue at Horizon Energy Services, it does not establish the required outcome: A user signs in once but is denied an application role that was never assigned.