Question 450
After the team responds to the following issue, which finding best demonstrates the desired security outcome? A legal document exchange service needs proof that a signer approved a specific contract revision.
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: A legal document exchange service needs proof that a signer approved a specific contract revision. It demonstrates that the proposed response, use verifiable digital signatures over canonical document content with trustworthy identity and timestamp evidence., produces the measurable result modification of a signed contract invalidates verification and the signer is traceable to the approved identity. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
In the problem “A legal document exchange service needs proof that a signer approved a specific contract revision”, evidence “A modified archived message fails integrity verification and the original version can be authenticated.” is not decisive because it tests “A hospital archives regulated emails but cannot verify whether messages were modified after storage”; the requested validation is modification of a signed contract invalidates verification and the signer is traceable to the approved identity.
For the issue “A legal document exchange service needs proof that a signer approved a specific contract revision”, measuring “An altered update fails signature verification while the original approved release installs.” would validate “A software vendor distributes update packages but clients cannot determine whether a binary was modified after signing” instead of the required control effect: modification of a signed contract invalidates verification and the signer is traceable to the approved identity.
Observation “Poisoned test responses fail while approved resolution reaches the expected signed records.” would be useful for “A branch site's DNS resolver returns spoofed responses after a malicious local host sends forged DNS replies”, but it does not prove that the response to “A legal document exchange service needs proof that a signer approved a specific contract revision” achieved the relevant outcome, modification of a signed contract invalidates verification and the signer is traceable to the approved identity.