Question 440
Which test or documented result best shows that the underlying issue was properly addressed? A software team wants to replace authenticated encryption with plain AES-CTR because it provides faster processing.
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: A software team wants to replace authenticated encryption with plain AES-CTR because it provides faster processing. It demonstrates that the proposed response, use an authenticated encryption design that protects both confidentiality and integrity and benchmark its performance., produces the measurable result tampered ciphertext fails verification while authorized throughput meets the defined service budget. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
This measurement is tied to “A cross-functional security group is considering a decision: A service encrypts records using AES-GCM but reuses a nonce with the same key for different messages” and the control “Enforce unique nonces per encryption key and reject unsafe reuse in the cryptographic library integration”. It cannot confirm that “Use an authenticated encryption design that protects both confidentiality and integrity and benchmark its performance” has achieved “Tampered ciphertext fails verification while authorized throughput meets the defined service budget” for the issue in this question.
Observation “A test computation returns authorized aggregates without revealing individual input records to peers.” would be useful for “A health analytics project needs joint computation across institutions without exposing raw patient datasets to other parties”, but it does not prove that the response to “A software team wants to replace authenticated encryption with plain AES-CTR because it provides faster processing” achieved the relevant outcome, tampered ciphertext fails verification while authorized throughput meets the defined service budget.
In the problem “A software team wants to replace authenticated encryption with plain AES-CTR because it provides faster processing”, evidence “A modified archived message fails integrity verification and the original version can be authenticated.” is not decisive because it tests “A hospital archives regulated emails but cannot verify whether messages were modified after storage”; the requested validation is tampered ciphertext fails verification while authorized throughput meets the defined service budget.