Question 340
During a migration readiness assessment at Horizon Energy Services, the SOC analyst identifies this issue: Several Conditional Access policies are configured but administrators assume only the first policy matching a user is evaluated. The responsible team reports that it has applied the correction. Which evidence BEST verifies that the original issue was resolved?
Explanation
Correct Answer
A policy simulation accounts for the cumulative applicable controls and flags the blocking rule responsible for a failed sign-in. This is the relevant proof because it tests whether the selected corrective action (Review all applicable policy assignments, conditions and resulting grant or block controls together) addressed the initiating problem (Several Conditional Access policies are configured but administrators assume only the first policy matching a user is evaluated) in Horizon Energy Services's remote field-worker sign-ins and operations environment, not merely whether a task was marked complete.
Incorrect Answers
The log shows simulated allow and block outcomes before the enforcement change is approved. This is useful evidence for a different situation (A security team wants to test a new block condition but turns it on for all users without an impact report) and action (Stage the Conditional Access change in report-only mode and review sign-in evaluation logs). For the reported issue at Horizon Energy Services, it does not establish the required outcome: A policy simulation accounts for the cumulative applicable controls and flags the blocking rule responsible for a failed sign-in.
An interactive test session prompts for reauthentication after the configured lifetime without expanding assigned roles. This is useful evidence for a different situation (An application has an excessive session lifetime but the team tries to fix it by granting users more directory roles) and action (Apply appropriate Conditional Access session controls such as sign-in frequency where supported). For the reported issue at Horizon Energy Services, it does not establish the required outcome: A policy simulation accounts for the cumulative applicable controls and flags the blocking rule responsible for a failed sign-in.
The external identity is denied the app after its assignment is removed even from an otherwise trusted network. This is useful evidence for a different situation (A temporary external collaborator retains access to an application because the Conditional Access policy trusts the network but does not govern authorization assignments) and action (Combine access policy conditions with scoped application authorization and timely entitlement removal). For the reported issue at Horizon Energy Services, it does not establish the required outcome: A policy simulation accounts for the cumulative applicable controls and flags the blocking rule responsible for a failed sign-in.