Question 20
Aspen Digital operates client advisory systems and shared files during a cross-tenant collaboration project. Its review records the following concern: A company deploys only a perimeter firewall and treats that one device as a complete defense against stolen credentials and malicious code. The responsible team reports that it has applied the correction. Which evidence BEST verifies that the original issue was resolved?
Explanation
Correct Answer
A tabletop exercise demonstrates that compromise of one layer is constrained by controls in another layer. This is the relevant proof because it tests whether the selected corrective action (Implement defense-in-depth with independent identity, network, device, application and data controls) addressed the initiating problem (A company deploys only a perimeter firewall and treats that one device as a complete defense against stolen credentials and malicious code) in Aspen Digital's client advisory systems and shared files environment, not merely whether a task was marked complete.
Incorrect Answers
A release audit confirms code vulnerabilities and secrets are addressed without attempting to patch provider-managed platform servers. This is useful evidence for a different situation (An Azure PaaS application team assumes managed runtime operations also transfer responsibility for application code and embedded credentials) and action (Keep application code security, permissions and credential handling in the customer workstream for the hosted PaaS service). For the reported issue at Aspen Digital, it does not establish the required outcome: A tabletop exercise demonstrates that compromise of one layer is constrained by controls in another layer.
An auditor can trace a policy requirement to its owner and reproducible control-operation evidence. This is useful evidence for a different situation (A compliance team treats a written security policy as proof the control is operating although no operational evidence is collected) and action (Link governance controls to measurable tests, monitoring and retained compliance evidence). For the reported issue at Aspen Digital, it does not establish the required outcome: A tabletop exercise demonstrates that compromise of one layer is constrained by controls in another layer.
A tenant review shows managed identities and document policies with separately documented Microsoft SaaS platform responsibilities. This is useful evidence for a different situation (A Microsoft 365 tenant assumes the SaaS provider alone must manage employee access and sensitivity settings for company documents) and action (Keep tenant identity, access and data classification controls under customer ownership while the SaaS provider operates the service). For the reported issue at Aspen Digital, it does not establish the required outcome: A tabletop exercise demonstrates that compromise of one layer is constrained by controls in another layer.