Question 40
A follow-up assurance review considers this problem: A financial-services team treats a breach of integrity-protected journal files as unlikely because the logs are encrypted. Which outcome best shows the intended improvement?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: A financial-services team treats a breach of integrity-protected journal files as unlikely because the logs are encrypted. It demonstrates that the proposed response, assess tampering and accountability separately from confidentiality, using remote append-only journaling and verification., produces the measurable result deliberate unauthorized record edits are detected with attributable integrity failures. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
Observation “A tabletop supplier breach produces a documented notification and evidence handoff within agreed contractual windows.” would be useful for “An outsourcing contract lacks any requirement for notification when a critical dependency suffers a security incident”, but it does not prove that the response to “A financial-services team treats a breach of integrity-protected journal files as unlikely because the logs are encrypted” achieved the relevant outcome, deliberate unauthorized record edits are detected with attributable integrity failures.
In “A telehealth vendor requires shared client administrator accounts to support all customer tenants”, “A test support operator cannot access another tenant and every privileged action is attributable” is the acceptance signal for “Evaluate supplier access risks and require isolated tenant scopes, individual attribution, and just-in-time support permissions”. The required proof for the selected response “Assess tampering and accountability separately from confidentiality, using remote append-only journaling and verification” is “Deliberate unauthorized record edits are detected with attributable integrity failures”.
For the issue “A financial-services team treats a breach of integrity-protected journal files as unlikely because the logs are encrypted”, measuring “A validated security diagram identifies command initiators and controls preventing unauthorized office-to-plant operations.” would validate “An IoT control architecture lacks a view of how operational commands cross between building automation and office IT” instead of the required control effect: deliberate unauthorized record edits are detected with attributable integrity failures.