Question 30
After the team responds to the following issue, which finding best demonstrates the desired security outcome? A hospital backup service shares administrators and credentials with production ransomware targets.
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: A hospital backup service shares administrators and credentials with production ransomware targets. It demonstrates that the proposed response, separate backup control-plane identity, enforce immutable offline recovery copies, and validate isolated restoration., produces the measurable result a test compromise of production credentials cannot delete recovery copies and an isolated restore succeeds. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
In the problem “A hospital backup service shares administrators and credentials with production ransomware targets”, evidence “Supplier onboarding cannot complete until documented authorized safeguards and applicable consent controls are verified.” is not decisive because it tests “A new subcontractor handles children's data, but procurement requests only a standard security questionnaire”; the requested validation is a test compromise of production credentials cannot delete recovery copies and an isolated restore succeeds.
For the issue “A hospital backup service shares administrators and credentials with production ransomware targets”, measuring “A test of unavailable primary credentials and region successfully restores protected service data elsewhere.” would validate “A platform team stores all backups in the same cloud account and region as the application” instead of the required control effect: a test compromise of production credentials cannot delete recovery copies and an isolated restore succeeds.
“Perform a business impact analysis accounting for revenue, customer disruption, regulatory exposure, and recovery dependencies” should produce “The risk register identifies outage consequences, approved recovery priorities, and an accountable business decision maker” in its own test case. The present requirement is instead checked by “A test compromise of production credentials cannot delete recovery copies and an isolated restore succeeds”, which validates “Separate backup control-plane identity, enforce immutable offline recovery copies, and validate isolated restoration” rather than the alternate control.