Question 340
A follow-up assurance review considers this problem: A site-to-site IPsec tunnel is operational but negotiates a deprecated cipher suite after its counterpart is upgraded. Which outcome best shows the intended improvement?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: A site-to-site IPsec tunnel is operational but negotiates a deprecated cipher suite after its counterpart is upgraded. It demonstrates that the proposed response, align IKE and ESP proposals to mutually supported approved cryptographic suites and key lifetimes., produces the measurable result tunnel negotiation selects the approved algorithms and rejects the deprecated proposal. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
In “An industrial robot controller accepts unauthenticated configuration updates over its plant network”, “Unauthorized workstations cannot change controller settings in an approved bench test” is the acceptance signal for “Restrict update paths to an approved engineering station and require signed or authenticated configuration where supported”. The required proof for the selected response “Align IKE and ESP proposals to mutually supported approved cryptographic suites and key lifetimes” is “Tunnel negotiation selects the approved algorithms and rejects the deprecated proposal”.
Observation “Poisoned test responses fail while approved resolution reaches the expected signed records.” would be useful for “A branch site's DNS resolver returns spoofed responses after a malicious local host sends forged DNS replies”, but it does not prove that the response to “A site-to-site IPsec tunnel is operational but negotiates a deprecated cipher suite after its counterpart is upgraded” achieved the relevant outcome, tunnel negotiation selects the approved algorithms and rejects the deprecated proposal.
For the issue “A site-to-site IPsec tunnel is operational but negotiates a deprecated cipher suite after its counterpart is upgraded”, measuring “An unauthorized application segment fails connectivity while approved application flows work.” would validate “A microsegmentation rule is intended to block application-to-database access but a permissive network ACL overrides the new rule” instead of the required control effect: tunnel negotiation selects the approved algorithms and rejects the deprecated proposal.