Question 280
A follow-up assurance review considers this problem: A device discovery project treats missing inventory data as trustworthy and silently grants privileged access to unidentified systems. Which outcome best shows the intended improvement?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: A device discovery project treats missing inventory data as trustworthy and silently grants privileged access to unidentified systems. It demonstrates that the proposed response, deny sensitive access until asset identity and posture meet attestation requirements., produces the measurable result unknown devices fail restricted access tests and enrollment records trace approved devices. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
The observed “Contract expiry ends access to the protected application even before the VPN session expires” validates the separate control “Adopt time-bound subject-to-resource grants and continuous authorization checks for contractor sessions” under “A company grants temporary external contractors standing application access because the VPN login remains valid for 30 days”. The present decision calls for the different result “Unknown devices fail restricted access tests and enrollment records trace approved devices” from “Deny sensitive access until asset identity and posture meet attestation requirements”.
In the problem “A device discovery project treats missing inventory data as trustworthy and silently grants privileged access to unidentified systems”, evidence “A test compute job outside the approved perimeter cannot read restricted training data.” is not decisive because it tests “A data science environment handles restricted data in a shared cluster but policy is enforced only at the internet edge”; the requested validation is unknown devices fail restricted access tests and enrollment records trace approved devices.
For the issue “A device discovery project treats missing inventory data as trustworthy and silently grants privileged access to unidentified systems”, measuring “The approved build uses a maintained library and associated security regression tests pass.” would validate “A vendor supplies a cryptographic library past its end-of-support date but integration teams assume compatibility equals security” instead of the required control effect: unknown devices fail restricted access tests and enrollment records trace approved devices.