Question 210
After the team responds to the following issue, which finding best demonstrates the desired security outcome? An application grants the same permissions to users in different regions despite local data-residency restrictions.
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: An application grants the same permissions to users in different regions despite local data-residency restrictions. It demonstrates that the proposed response, introduce attribute-based authorization using jurisdiction, data classification, role, and contextual conditions., produces the measurable result cross-region attempts to retrieve restricted records fail while permitted local access succeeds. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
“A simulated device-compliance failure revokes sensitive application access pending revalidation” would verify “Add risk-based continuous authorization and context-triggered reauthentication for sensitive actions” for the situation “An identity provider treats a user session as trustworthy indefinitely after MFA, even when device posture becomes compromised”. Here the required evidence is “Cross-region attempts to retrieve restricted records fail while permitted local access succeeds” after “Introduce attribute-based authorization using jurisdiction, data classification, role, and contextual conditions”; the alternative observation does not test that control.
“A sample evidence transfer records recipient, hash, permission, timestamp, and access revocation” would verify “Architect a restricted evidence repository with immutable audit history, access approval, and retention controls” for the situation “A multinational shares incident evidence with external legal counsel through ordinary shared mailboxes with no chain of custody”. Here the required evidence is “Cross-region attempts to retrieve restricted records fail while permitted local access succeeds” after “Introduce attribute-based authorization using jurisdiction, data classification, role, and contextual conditions”; the alternative observation does not test that control.
This measurement is tied to “An application uses push MFA with unlimited retries after repeated suspicious prompts and a possible fatigue attack” and the control “Limit push challenges and require phishing-resistant step-up authentication for privileged activity”. It cannot confirm that “Introduce attribute-based authorization using jurisdiction, data classification, role, and contextual conditions” has achieved “Cross-region attempts to retrieve restricted records fail while permitted local access succeeds” for the issue in this question.