Question 160
A follow-up assurance review considers this problem: A supplier offers preloaded network hardware whose firmware integrity cannot be independently validated. Which outcome best shows the intended improvement?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: A supplier offers preloaded network hardware whose firmware integrity cannot be independently validated. It demonstrates that the proposed response, require manufacturer-signed firmware verification and approved chain-of-custody checks at receiving., produces the measurable result a tampered firmware image fails device attestation and the receipt is quarantined. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
In “A testing team frequently skips security regression on minor user-interface updates, accidentally reintroducing unsafe redirect handling”, “A deliberately unsafe redirect change fails before production deployment” is the acceptance signal for “Include targeted security regression checks in automated pipelines based on changed components and threat coverage”. The required proof for the selected response “Require manufacturer-signed firmware verification and approved chain-of-custody checks at receiving” is “A tampered firmware image fails device attestation and the receipt is quarantined”.
Observation “An unauthorized role fails a documented negative test and the control maps to its original requirement.” would be useful for “A medical IoT application has security requirements only as general text with no testable authorization behavior”, but it does not prove that the response to “A supplier offers preloaded network hardware whose firmware integrity cannot be independently validated” achieved the relevant outcome, a tampered firmware image fails device attestation and the receipt is quarantined.
For the issue “A supplier offers preloaded network hardware whose firmware integrity cannot be independently validated”, measuring “An unsigned or altered image fails admission while the verified release is deployed.” would validate “A container deployment uses a publicly accessible image registry with no signature verification in production admission” instead of the required control effect: a tampered firmware image fails device attestation and the receipt is quarantined.