Question 140
Which test or documented result best shows that the underlying issue was properly addressed? A manufacturing site uses a passive packet tap for monitoring but expects it to enforce an automatic block on production control traffic.
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: A manufacturing site uses a passive packet tap for monitoring but expects it to enforce an automatic block on production control traffic. It demonstrates that the proposed response, separate passive detection from an appropriately governed inline enforcement design that respects operational safety., produces the measurable result test malicious traffic generates monitoring alerts and only the approved enforcement device blocks the designated flows. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
In “A cross-functional security group is considering a decision: A financial branch allows stale device attestation to authorize trading operations after a laptop fails compliance scanning”, “A noncompliant test device loses privileged transaction access pending successful reattestation” is the acceptance signal for “Require current device health attestation and step-up approval for sensitive transaction initiation”. The required proof for the selected response “Separate passive detection from an appropriately governed inline enforcement design that respects operational safety” is “Test malicious traffic generates monitoring alerts and only the approved enforcement device blocks the designated flows”.
Observation “An intentional proxy outage maintains approved customer transactions through the redundant path.” would be useful for “A bank uses a single reverse proxy for all online services and has no maintenance bypass or failover method”, but it does not prove that the response to “A manufacturing site uses a passive packet tap for monitoring but expects it to enforce an automatic block on production control traffic” achieved the relevant outcome, test malicious traffic generates monitoring alerts and only the approved enforcement device blocks the designated flows.
For the issue “A manufacturing site uses a passive packet tap for monitoring but expects it to enforce an automatic block on production control traffic”, measuring “A simulated upstream failure stays within the dependent workload's error budget and does not cascade.” would validate “An industrial analytics service adds a second upstream API without defining failure limits and propagates timeouts to core production systems” instead of the required control effect: test malicious traffic generates monitoring alerts and only the approved enforcement device blocks the designated flows.