Question 340
Which ongoing review or control is most appropriate for avoiding a repeat of the following project incident? A railway signal design is reviewed solely by its author before being handed over for independent safety approval.
Explanation
Correct Answer
The lasting control is: Require independence and reviewer competence for high-risk product quality activities. It addresses recurrence of this mechanism: The quality method lacks appropriate independent review for a high-consequence product. A successful system should still demonstrate: A competent reviewer signs off the design against defined safety and interface criteria.
Incorrect Answers
The option addresses cases in which product configuration and quality status are not maintained as a trustworthy management record. In the reported incident, the quality method lacks appropriate independent review for a high-consequence product instead.
This safeguard is useful when defect handling is not proportionate to acceptance tolerances and authorized concessions. It does not prevent the present fault, where the quality method lacks appropriate independent review for a high-consequence product.
The proposed routine targets situations in which technical quality tests have not covered complete user acceptance expectations. To prevent the reported problem, the team must address the fact that the quality method lacks appropriate independent review for a high-consequence product.