Question 540
After the team responds to the following issue, which finding best demonstrates the desired security outcome? An internal service uses a cryptographic erase process but continues retaining unencrypted replicas in a secondary analytics pipeline.
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: An internal service uses a cryptographic erase process but continues retaining unencrypted replicas in a secondary analytics pipeline. It demonstrates that the proposed response, inventory all replica locations and apply lifecycle disposal consistently across encrypted and plaintext copies., produces the measurable result post-disposal sampling finds no recoverable restricted records in either primary or secondary stores. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
“Use transactional atomic operations or appropriate locking around the shared balance invariant” should produce “Concurrent test withdrawals cannot exceed the authorized balance” in its own test case. The present requirement is instead checked by “Post-disposal sampling finds no recoverable restricted records in either primary or secondary stores”, which validates “Inventory all replica locations and apply lifecycle disposal consistently across encrypted and plaintext copies” rather than the alternate control.
Observation “The hunt records available indicators without interrupting medical device operation.” would be useful for “A hunting team uses intrusive scans against safety-critical medical devices without permission because an intelligence report lists a common CVE”, but it does not prove that the response to “An internal service uses a cryptographic erase process but continues retaining unencrypted replicas in a secondary analytics pipeline” achieved the relevant outcome, post-disposal sampling finds no recoverable restricted records in either primary or secondary stores.
For the issue “An internal service uses a cryptographic erase process but continues retaining unencrypted replicas in a secondary analytics pipeline”, measuring “Reverse inspection finds no reusable database secret and unauthorized API access is denied.” would validate “A mobile application embeds a global database password in its package, allowing anyone with the app to access backend records” instead of the required control effect: post-disposal sampling finds no recoverable restricted records in either primary or secondary stores.