Question 510
After the team responds to the following issue, which finding best demonstrates the desired security outcome? A service retrieves user-provided URLs on its backend and can contact cloud instance metadata addresses.
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is direct test evidence of the control objective in the case: A service retrieves user-provided URLs on its backend and can contact cloud instance metadata addresses. It demonstrates that the proposed response, restrict server-side request destinations, redirect handling, and approved network egress to prevent SSRF., produces the measurable result requests targeting metadata or private IP ranges fail while sanctioned external URLs still work. The observation tests a relevant security outcome rather than an unrelated control or reporting activity.
Incorrect Answers
In the problem “A service retrieves user-provided URLs on its backend and can contact cloud instance metadata addresses”, evidence “The report separately records verified archive activity and any proven external transmission.” is not decisive because it tests “An enterprise creates a security incident report with unverified statements that data was exfiltrated because a large archive file exists”; the requested validation is requests targeting metadata or private IP ranges fail while sanctioned external URLs still work.
The observed “An altered or untrusted tooling package fails the signed provenance gate” validates the separate control “Validate supplier integrity, package signatures, and the software dependency chain before promotion” under “A container image includes untrusted firmware update tooling supplied by a partner without signature or dependency review”. The present decision calls for the different result “Requests targeting metadata or private IP ranges fail while sanctioned external URLs still work” from “Restrict server-side request destinations, redirect handling, and approved network egress to prevent SSRF”.
Observation “A controlled reflected-XSS payload is displayed harmlessly without executing in the browser.” would be useful for “A customer portal's search field reflects script content into user responses and the team proposes only a perimeter firewall rule”, but it does not prove that the response to “A service retrieves user-provided URLs on its backend and can contact cloud instance metadata addresses” achieved the relevant outcome, requests targeting metadata or private IP ranges fail while sanctioned external URLs still work.